This article Using Psychology to Save You From Yourself was very interesting. I learned about behavioral economics, defined as "a school of economic thought greatly influenced by psychological research — which argues that the human animal is hard-wired to make errors when it comes to decision-making, and therefore people need a little 'nudge' to make decisions that are in their own best interests." Apparently obscure psychological research into human decision-making back in 1955 later revolutionized economics. Daniel Kahneman, an Israeli psychologist, won a Nobel Prize in economics for his work on the subject of the "illusion of validity," a phrase he coined. "From stockbrokers to baseball scouts, people have a huge amount of confidence in their own judgment, even in the face of evidence that their judgment is wrong," according to the article.
Kahneman worked with psychologist Amos Tversky cataloging the ways the human mind systematically misjudges the world around it. Enter economist Richard Thaler, now a well-respected professor at the University of Chicago, who was intrigued by the idea of integrating psychological research and economics. The three of them began to publish their ideas, and initially, mainstream economists largely rejected the work. Economists had been working under the assumption that rational human beings can be counted on to make the best choice for themselves. The new research countered that notion and presented evidence (through research, of course) that flawed decision-making occurs more often than not.
Cass Sunstein and Thaler wrote a book titled Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth and Happiness. Sunstein, a Harvard Law professor, is President Obama's pick to head the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, and apparently there are a number of high-level appointees now working in the Obama administration who favor this kind of approach. There is also a blog called Nudge which I found interesting.
Looking back at how many times in my lifetime my judgment turned out to be WRONG - big-time - I am glad to know research backs up this judgment about my judgment.
Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Research. Show all posts
Friday, July 31, 2009
My Personal Learning Network #3
Since my brain seems to be completely occupied with research (a result of taking a research course in grad school), I find myself drawn to articles written about the “R” word. Amazing how many there are, when you start paying attention. Research really IS everywhere I look these days, and as I learn more about it, I look at it all a little bit differently.
For PLN #3, I will focus on what my Google Reader found to further fill my brain with research topics. Here’s one for my brain ABOUT my brain. What educators can learn from brain research: Breakthroughs in neuroscience are measuring brain response to stimuli and beginning to alter classroom practices. “Enriching and informing classroom practices,” to be exact, which sounds interesting to me. Researchers are using functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to scan the brain and measure neural activity in response to stimuli. This has led to a concept called neuroplasticity, meaning the brain's structure is more flexible than previously thought. The article mentions studies that measure reading aptitudes, the causes of and workings of attention-deficit disorder, and the way the brain processes mathematics.
Michael Atherton, a researcher in the Department of Educational Psychology at the University of Minnesota, describes a methodological framework to assess how applicable a study might be for classroom implementation. There are three progressive stages to this framework: Discovery, Functional analysis, and Pedagogical evaluation. According to Atherton, studies that answer the question "Which pedagogical method results in students achieving higher levels of performance?" fit into this last category and can be used to guide instructional design. To me, that just seems like such common sense.
This article came to me from eSchool News, to which I used to subscribe, but now have added to my feed in Google Reader. eSchool News also gave me this interesting article. It tells about Project RED (for Revolutionizing EDucation) which will “examine the outcomes of educational technology initiatives using a cost-benefit analysis to determine which ed-tech programs and devices are having the most cost-effective impact for schools, parents, and states.” According to Jeanne Hayes of the Hayes Connection, one of the consulting firms leading the project, very little research has been done to show the connection between educational technology and cost savings. This does not surprise me.
After identifying and selecting schools that have implemented “ubiquitous technology initiatives,” data gathering will begin. The data will be used to develop a framework for determining which programs and services are most effective in raising achievement. In the next phase, several partner states will join with Project RED to examine larger factors that may be influenced by ed-tech initiatives, and how much money can be saved by using virtual learning. The final phase will deliver data and findings to stakeholders. The project is expected to take about a year. I will be very interested to see the results.
For PLN #3, I will focus on what my Google Reader found to further fill my brain with research topics. Here’s one for my brain ABOUT my brain. What educators can learn from brain research: Breakthroughs in neuroscience are measuring brain response to stimuli and beginning to alter classroom practices. “Enriching and informing classroom practices,” to be exact, which sounds interesting to me. Researchers are using functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to scan the brain and measure neural activity in response to stimuli. This has led to a concept called neuroplasticity, meaning the brain's structure is more flexible than previously thought. The article mentions studies that measure reading aptitudes, the causes of and workings of attention-deficit disorder, and the way the brain processes mathematics.
Michael Atherton, a researcher in the Department of Educational Psychology at the University of Minnesota, describes a methodological framework to assess how applicable a study might be for classroom implementation. There are three progressive stages to this framework: Discovery, Functional analysis, and Pedagogical evaluation. According to Atherton, studies that answer the question "Which pedagogical method results in students achieving higher levels of performance?" fit into this last category and can be used to guide instructional design. To me, that just seems like such common sense.
This article came to me from eSchool News, to which I used to subscribe, but now have added to my feed in Google Reader. eSchool News also gave me this interesting article. It tells about Project RED (for Revolutionizing EDucation) which will “examine the outcomes of educational technology initiatives using a cost-benefit analysis to determine which ed-tech programs and devices are having the most cost-effective impact for schools, parents, and states.” According to Jeanne Hayes of the Hayes Connection, one of the consulting firms leading the project, very little research has been done to show the connection between educational technology and cost savings. This does not surprise me.
After identifying and selecting schools that have implemented “ubiquitous technology initiatives,” data gathering will begin. The data will be used to develop a framework for determining which programs and services are most effective in raising achievement. In the next phase, several partner states will join with Project RED to examine larger factors that may be influenced by ed-tech initiatives, and how much money can be saved by using virtual learning. The final phase will deliver data and findings to stakeholders. The project is expected to take about a year. I will be very interested to see the results.
Tuesday, June 23, 2009
Value Added Analysis

This article in The New Yorker magazine was shared with me by a non-teaching friend. I found it absolutely fascinating. The article makes many comparisons with the process by which NFL scouts select promising quarterback candidates and the ability to predict teacher effectiveness. If you not are interested in professional football, you may want to skip over the lengthy analogy. On to the research...
According to the author, Malcolm Gladwell, “A group of researchers -- Thomas J. Kane, an economist at Harvard’s school of education; Douglas Staiger, an economist at Dartmouth; and Robert Gordon, a policy analyst at the Center for American Progress -- have investigated whether it helps to have a teacher who has earned a teaching certification or a master’s degree. Both are expensive, time-consuming credentials that almost every district expects teachers to acquire; neither makes a difference in the classroom.”
In answering the question of what actually does matter in making a great teacher, Gladwell refers us to the work of Jacob Kounin, an educational researcher. Kounin called that indefinable ability “withitness.” This quality is defined as “a teacher’s communicating to the children by her actual behavior (rather than by verbally announcing: ‘I know what’s going on’) that she knows what the children are doing, or has the proverbial ‘eyes in the back of her head.’” Of course, this ability cannot possibly be demonstrated until a teacher actually stands in front of a classroom.
"One of the most important tools in contemporary educational research is 'value added' analysis. It uses standardized test scores to look at how much the academic performance of students in a given teacher’s classroom changes between the beginning and the end of the school year." The conclusion drawn by the author (and supported by research) is that you simply can’t tell from a piece of paper who’ll be effective in a classroom.
This is an interesting point to consider as we all progress toward another one of those pieces of paper.
Labels:
Master's Degree,
Research,
The New Yorker Magazine
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

